The 2025 fireplace market is packed with options. That’s great for design freedom, but it can cause decision overload.
Electric fireplaces lead on simplicity, placement, and low maintenance. Gas fireplaces win on real flame, higher BTU heat, and long-term heating value.
Start with your goal: ambiance, heat, or both. This guide compares how each type works, what it costs to install and run, and where each one fits best—so you can buy with confidence.
Quick snapshot:
Electric fireplaces create flame effects using LED projection, holographic visuals, or fine water-vapor systems. Heat comes from a fan-forced element or infrared heater. Most plug into a 120 V outlet; larger built-ins may need a dedicated circuit. Typical draw is 1.5–2.0 kW.
Explore more: Shop our core categories for a sense of styles and price bands — Electric Fireplaces.
Specific examples: SimpliFire SF-BI30-EB, SimpliFire SF-BI36-EB, SimpliFire SF-ALLP50-BK, Napoleon Astound 62", Dimplex Ignite Evolve Linear.
Deeper reading: Fireplace Efficiency Guide, Fireplace Running Costs 2025.
Gas models burn natural gas or propane through precision burners with log or glass media. Venting options include direct-vent (sealed), vent-free (where allowed), and B-vent. Ignition systems range from standing pilot to intermittent electronic ignition.
Explore more: Browse our gas lineup — Gas Fireplaces (Direct-Vent).
Specific examples: Empire Rushmore TruFlame 50" Clean-Face, Empire Rushmore 30" Direct-Vent Insert, Empire Rushmore 35" Direct-Vent Insert, Empire VFD30CC Cast Iron Gas Stove, White Mountain Hearth 152 cm Double-Sided.
Deeper reading: Direct-Vent vs Vent-Free Fireplaces, Built-In vs Insert vs Freestanding.
Electric: DIY-friendly for wall-mounts and many recessed units; finishing is straightforward. Typical all-in: $500–$3,500 depending on size and carpentry.
Gas: Requires licensed installers, vent routing, gas line, and inspection. Typical all-in: $2,500–$9,000 depending on run length, vent path, and finishing.
Electric converts nearly all input power to heat at the appliance, but electricity can cost more per delivered BTU. Gas units have 70–90% AFUE efficiency and often cost less to run per hour for the same heat output.
Helpful resources: Energy.gov: estimating appliance energy use, EIA: average retail electricity prices.
Electric has evolved (color palettes, ember beds, vapor effects), but gas provides true combustion and radiant glow. Choose electric for modern linear looks; choose gas for classic, lifelike flames.
Electric has no onsite emissions; total footprint depends on local power mix. Gas produces CO₂ but far less particulate than wood. For code and best practices, see HPBA: codes & regulatory resources.
| Type | Unit Price | Install | Typical Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electric | $500–$3,000 | $0–$500 | $500–$3,500 |
| Gas | $1,500–$6,000 | $1,000–$3,000 | $2,500–$9,000 |
Electric: 1.5 kW × hours × local kWh rate. At $0.15/kWh and 2 hrs/day, ~ $9–$12/month.
Gas: Input BTU ÷ 100,000 = therms × local rate. At $1.20/therm and ~25k BTU/hr for 2 hrs/day, ~$12–$18/month (usage and AFUE apply).
Electric lifespans average 15–20 years; gas 20–25 years with annual service. Gas tends to add more resale value for built-ins; electric adds convenience and design versatility.
Related internal reads: Electric vs Gas Fireplace Cost (2025), 2025 Fireplace Buying Guide.
Popular internal products to compare: Empire Rushmore 50 Clean-Face, Napoleon Astound 62" Electric.
Helpful internal reads: How to Clean a Fireplace Safely, Pre-Winter Fireplace Checklist.
Rule of thumb: choose electric for convenience, low maintenance, and flexible placement; choose gas for higher heat, realism, and long-term value.
Want to compare more? Start at Electric Fireplaces and Gas Fireplaces, then shortlist by size, style, and install method.
Which is cheaper to run? In most regions, gas costs less per BTU than electricity. Check local utility rates: EIA electricity, EIA natural gas.
Are gas fireplaces safe for bedrooms? Only if the model is approved for bedroom use and local codes permit. Direct-vent units are typically preferred.
Do electric fireplaces work during outages? No, they require power. Gas may operate (model dependent), but blowers, lights, or controls could need electricity.
Can I install a gas fireplace myself? No. Most jurisdictions require licensed installation, permits, and inspection for safety and code compliance.
How long do they last? Electric ~15–20 years; gas ~20–25 years with annual servicing.
More internal guides: Fireplace Trends 2025, Installation Options: Built-In vs Insert vs Freestanding.
If you want effortless installation, flexible placement, and low maintenance, choose electric. If you need stronger heat, authentic flame, and long-term value, choose gas. Either way, pick the model that fits your room size, layout, and budget—then install it correctly for safe, efficient performance.
Next steps: Shortlist a few models, compare BTU needs and install path, then schedule a consult. Browse Electric and Gas to get started.
{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}
Leave a comment